Skip to main content

TWISTED REALITY (BABY REINDEER)

© Netflix

Every now and again a TV show comes out of the blue with a relatively unknown cast and is a surprise success.

'Stranger Things' springs to mind.

'Beef' is another.

Now Netflix has done it again with 'Baby Reindeer'.

© Netflix

Based on its star Richard Gadd's acclaimed autobiographical one man show of the same name, it's a twisted tale about stalking.

Constantly bucking expectations, the show strays into territory the viewer might find disturbing and surprising, subverting usual victim narratives.

Drawing on his own experience of being hounded in real life, Gadd plays a fictionalised version of himself, Donny Dunn - a struggling stand up comedian who works during the day in a London pub.

A wannabe Vic Reeves, he's a reserved guy offstage who is still on good terms with an ex girlfriend, Shalom Brune-Franklin's Keeley's mum.

Nina Sosanya's Liz is even his landlady.

© Netflix

While working on a shift, he takes pity on a distraught customer Jessica Gunning's Martha Scott who comes into the pub, giving her a cup of tea on the house.

From that one brief act she is smitten, coming into the pub every day to converse with him and increasingly flirt with him.

Martha's romantic fixation with Donny amuses his fellow workers, Michael Wildman's Greggsy and Danny Kirrane's Gino.

She even has a nickname for him "Baby Reindeer" and gabbles away with tales about being a wealthy lawyer.

© Netflix

But the laughter soon gives way to concern when she gets his email and starts to bombard him with hundreds of messages each day.

Meeting Martha for a coffee, he is particularly disturbed by a meltdown she has in the cafe.

Bizarrely, he secretly follows her home - discovering that she lives in a council flat and is then spotted peeking in her window.

Interpreting this as a sign that he is romantically interested, Martha begins to insert herself even more into various aspects of his life.

She turns up at stand-up gigs where he is dying onstage and even befriends Liz to get into his home to leave photographs of herself in her underwear in his bedroom.

© Netflix

She threatens Keeley after tracking her down on Facebook, believing she is still his girlfriend.

However she gets really mad when she discovers about Teri, an American therapist who Donny starts dating.

Even though Donny subsequently discovers online that she has a history of stalking, he is slow to alert the police to her obsessive behaviour.

But then her behaviour and his really spirals out of control.

© Netflix

'Baby Reindeer' has sparked a debate in the UK about stalking and coercive control but it's also a complex tale that doesn't simply boil the issue down to Martha being a bunny boiler like Glenn Close's Alex in Adrian Lynn's hit 1987 movie 'Fatal Attraction'.

It  doesn't just focus on stalking but also on Donny's baffling behaviour.

While not justifying his treatment at the hands of Martha, Donny nonetheless behaves inexplicably throughout the show, developing a fascination with his stalker to the point where it puts his own safety and sanity at risk.

The risky situations he finds himself in also do not just involve Martha.

© Netflix

Throughout the miniseries, Donny confounds viewers by sabotaging any prospects he has of a stable, happy relationship.

All of this makes for uncomfortable viewing.

There are moments of grim sexual violence in the show that are hard to watch - particularly in the fourth episode.

But even the way this is handled by Gadd and directors Weronika Tofilska and Josephine Bournebusch is not quite how you might expect.

© Netflix

The explicit nature of Gadd's story and his narration will remind viewers of Danny Boyle's influential adaptation of Irvine Welsh's novel and play 'Trainspotting'.

However unlike Boyle's film, 'Baby Reindeer' lacks visual panache and at times it struggles to shake off its theatrical origins.

In spite of its contradictions and flaws, it's still a challenging and undoubtedly fascinating watch.

As Donny hurtles into one catastrophe after another, it's a bit like watching a succession of car crashes.

© Netflix

As for the performances, Gadd and Gunning understandably dominate the show.

The former undoubtedly engages our sympathies but also puzzles with Donny's erratic behaviour.

His is not a broad brush depiction of a victim of abuse - it is multi-layered and contradictory.

Gunning, who some viewers will know from Stephen Merchant's 'The Outlaws,' shows there are more strings to her bow than just being a comic actress.

She successfully toys with the audience's emotions in the show - appalling audiences with her obsessive and abusive behaviour but then hinting at a desperate loneliness that starkly comes into view when Martha explains where the nickname "Baby Reindeer" came from.

© Netflix

Sosanya, Brune-Franklin, Wildman, Kirrane and Thomas Coombes as a gormless police officer who Donny eventually reports Martha's criminal behaviour to, provide sturdy support.

Amanda Root and Mark Lewis-Jones amuse and surprise as Donny's seemingly straightlaced parents back home in Scotland, Elle and Gerry.

However there are two members of the supporting cast who really leave their mark.

Mexican filmmaker and actress Nava Mau dazzles as Teri with a performance that will challenge audience prejudices and attitudes.

© Netflix

Tom Goodman-Hill also turns in a haunting performance as Darrien O'Connor, a TV comedy writer who takes Donny under his wing.

There are so many surprises in 'Baby Reindeer,' that just like Neil Jordan's 'The Crying Game,' you are desperate not to spoil them in any review.

The show is, in truth, a bit of a rollercoaster ride but it will not be for everyone.

When you climb off Gadd's rollercoaster, it's dizzying and disorientating to the extent that you're not quite sure how you feel about the show in its immediate aftermath.

© Netflix

'Baby Reindeer' certainly packs a lot of issues into it's seven episodes and it's crying out for an academic treatise on what it has to say about the psychology of victims and their abusers.

There's no doubt it is one of the most memorable shows you'll see on any TV platform this year, if you can stomach the graphic content.

It announces Gunning, Goodman-Hill, Mau and Gadd as actors to keep an eye on.

Gadd's revelation that the show is autobiographical has ironically triggered an online witch hunt by viewers who have tried to unmask the real stalker who inspired it.

© Netflix


But there's no doubt that what Gadd is really trying to do is shine a light on the complexity of abuse from the perspective of the victim.

Is it on a par with Michaela Coel's equally complex and challenging tale of sexual abuse, 'I May Destroy You'?

Not quite but it is reminiscent of that BBC show and it will certainly have you thinking about it days afterwards.

And if it sparks conversations about stalking, coercive control, sexual abuse and support for victims, then that's surely a good thing?

('Baby Reindeer' was made available for streaming on Netflix on April 11, 2024)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A FAMILY DIVIDED (KIN, SEASON TWO)

© RTE & AMC+ Recently  in a review of 'The Dry' for the Slugger O'Toole website,  I wrote about it being a golden age for Irish TV drama. And it is. Last year saw Sharon Horgan's Irish Film and Television Award winning black comedy ' Bad Sisters ' delight audiences on Apple TV+. Fran Harris ' The Dry ' has made a bit of a splash on Britbox, RTE and ITVx. ©  RTE & AMC+ North of the border, Channel 4's ' Derry Girls ' and BBC Northern Ireland's 'Three Families' and ' Blue Lights ' have really impressed audiences. However over the past eight weeks, one show has muscled its way back to the front of the pack. 'Kin' is a gangland drama made by RTE and AMC. The first series hit our screens in September 2021 and made an immediate impression with its high production values and gripping storyline. © RTE & AMC+ The tale of a south Dublin crime family, the Kinsellas sucked into a feud with a more powerful gang hea

FATHER TIME (FRASIER - REBOOT, SEASON ONE)

© Paramount+ & CBS Studios It's been one of the most eagerly anticipated shows of 2023. It's also been one of the year's most feared shows. 'Frasier' - The Reboot was always going to have huge expectations to live up to. For 11 seasons, the original show was a massive ratings draw on NBC in the US and on other TV stations around the world. © Paramount+ & CBS Studios Adored by critics as much as it was by audiences, the 'Cheers' spin-off built up a huge fanbase with a combination of smart writing and brilliant comedy acting. It netted an impressive haul of 37 Primetime Emmy awards. Even after the final episode aired in May 2004, the Seattle-based sitcom has remained a constant presence on our TV screens, with Channel 4 in the UK airing it every morning. So when it was announced in 2021 that Kelsey Grammer was reviving the sitcom, there was considerable joy in some quarters and trepidation in others. © Paramount+ & CBS Studios Many wondered how wou

TWO SOULS COLLIDE (BALLYWALTER)

© Breakout Pictures & Elysian 'Ballywalter' isn't about Ballywalter. The Northern Irish coastal village simply provides a backdrop for director Prasanna Puranawajah and screenwriter Stacey Gregg's delicate tale of damaged souls coming into each other's orbit and helping each other cope. If anything, Belfast features more than Ballywalter in Puranawajah's movie but we know  that title was already taken . Seana Kerslake plays Eileen, a twentysomething university dropout who has gone off the rails and is back living with her mum, Abigail McGibbon's Jen. Taking on the job of a taxi driver, she has to endure the opinions of customers who don't think it's a job for a woman. © Breakout Pictures & Elysian Eileen doubles as a barista and can be pretty spiky with the customers in both jobs. Disillusioned and dejected, she hides behind drink as she struggles to come to terms with the death of her father, the sudden ending of a relationship with a cheati