Skip to main content

WORTH THE WEIGHT? (THE WHALE)

© A24

It's easy to see why people are getting so riled about 'The Whale'.

Darren Aronofsky is one of those directors who always seems to make in your face movies that are about as subtle as a breeze block.

However 'The Whale' takes that to a whole new level.

It takes a play about a sensitive issue - morbid obesity - and turns it into a movie that just smacks of awards clickbait.

© A24

And in that regard it has succeedex, with its star Brendan Fraser winning Best Actor at the Critics Choice and Screen Actors Guild awards and engaging in a tight three way battle for the Oscar with Austin Butler and Colin Farrell.

Based on the 2012 play of the same name by Samuel D Hunter, Fraser plays Charlie, a reclusive, morbidly obese English lecturer who is believed to have only a week to live.

At the start of Aronofsky's movie, Charlie is giving an online creative writing tutorial to college students via Zoom but keeps his webcam switched off, still pretending it is broken.

After the lesson, he is watching gay porn and masturbating when Ty Simpkins' Thomas bangs on his front door and enters his living room.

© A24

Perilously close to inducing a cardiac arrest, Charlie gets Thomas to read him an essay about Herman Melville's 'Miby Dick' to calm him down.

Asking him why he has turned up on his door, Thomas tells Charlie he is a missionary from the New Life Church who is spreading the word of God from door to door.

However he is soon ushered out of the house by Charlie's carer, Hong Chau's nurse Liz who not only tends to her friend's medical needs but buys him groceries while he remains cooped up in the house struggling with his mobility.

Liz's pleads with him yo go to the hospital for treatment but ignores her request.

© A24

But as the film unfolds, we learn Charlie has also reached out to his estranged, angry teenage daughter Sadie Sink's Ellie who he offers to help with her essays for high school.

Ellie's mum, Samantha Morton's Mary has kept her out of his life ever since he left them when the child was eight to embark on another relationship with a man.

That man turns out to have been Liz's brother.

And when Thomas returns to apparently convert Charlie, it is also revealed that Liz has family connections to the New Church mission and blames them for her brother's suicide which has also driven her patient to morbid obesity.

© A24

Aronofsky and Hunter keep several plates spinning throughout the movie as truths are revealed about the various characters.

But is 'The Whale' worthy of all the awards buzz it has received over the past three months?

In many ways, 'The Whale' is a typical Aronofsky film - visceral, physical, uncompromising fare that is not afraid to repulse its viewers.

However it's a movie that really struggles to shake off the rigid straitjacket of its theatrical origins.

'The Whale' feels like a televised version of a play and, therefore, feels quite flat.

© A24

As for the performances, Fraser, Chau, Simpkins, Sink and Morton show a lot of commitment to their roles.

Fraser, in particular, dons prosthetics and a fat suit to convey the physical challenges faced by his character.

However 'The Whale' is very much a Marmite film.

It inevitably sharply divides audiences - some of whom will lap up the histrionics and think it is an acting triumph and others who find it gratuitous, insulting, distasteful nonsense.

If you haven't discerned this already, I fall into the latter camp.

© A24

Aronofsky overdoes the "isn't he repulsive?" shots of Charlie's body to the point where the shots seem like fat shaming.

Yet his and Fraser's attempts to counteract that with moments when Charlie's emotional fragility are on display also smack of clumsy audience manipulation.

Worst of all, Aronofsky struggles to overcome the limitations of shooting his film just in one room, meaning the movie really feels as fake as a studio based TV play.

What the film does is to remind you what a superb job Lenny Abrahamson and his cinematographer Danny Cohen did in their 2015 Oscar nominated adaptation of Emma Donoghue's 'Room'.

© A24

Both operated in an even more confined space than Aronofsky and his cinematographer Matthew Libatique and yet they managed to somehow turn that set into something much more cinematic.

Unfortunately for Fraser, in particular, the theatricality of the film and the lack of spectacle means all the audience is left with is the wheezing, the grunting, the weeping and the heartfelt speeches.

And that just makes it appear like obvious Oscar baiting.

You can almost predict the clips that will be selected for screening during Academy Awards night for him and Best Supporting Actress nominee Chau.

© A24

As the film reaches its inevitably overwrought climax, it completely loses its grip and worse still, the final scebes may induce derisory laughter among some viewers.

This isn't really fair on Fraser, in particular, who certainly gives his all in the main role.

Ultimately he is let down by a screenplay that sounds just too written and direction that lacks imagination.

Rather than really engage with its subject, Aronofsky prefers to wallow in the misery of a morbidly obese man crying while smothering pizza in mayo and then gorging on Cheeto sandwiches before spewing in a bin.

© A24

'The Whale' is a film that lacks subtlety, sensitivity or any real compassion.

It just seems more concerned with pushing audience buttons - not for the first time in Aronofsky's career.

And that is shameful because an issue like morbid obesity deserves much better handling than this.

The other tragedy is watching Fraser's efforts to elevate the film prove so fruitless.

Try as he might, he is ultimately defeated by Hunter's gauche writing and Aronofsky's uninspiring, heavy handed direction which result in a film that lacks the requisite heart to be taken as seriously as it should have.

('The Whale' was released in UK and Irish cinemas on February 3, 2023)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

THE FIGHTING IRISH (SAIPAN)

SAIPAN Some films are irresistible to audiences because of their subject matter. Movies like Oliver Stone's ' JFK ,' Stephen Frears' ' The Queen ' or Paul Greengrass' ' United 93 ' fall into that category, drawing cinemagoers because of their depiction of events that occurred in their lifetime. Lisa Barros D'Sa and Glenn Leyburn's movie 'Saipan' falls into that category too because it depicts a story from 2002 that transcended sport and became a major news event not just in Ireland but around the world. In 2002, the Republic of Ireland's star footballer Roy Keane  did the unthinkable . On the Pacific island of Saipan, he turned his back on another chance to represent his country and play on soccer's greatest stage, the World Cup. The Corkman left the squad after a blistering row with his manager over the Football Association of Ireland's poor preparations for the tournament. Many people in the sport and Ireland believed he...

BEG, BORROW AND STEAL (MARTY SUPREME & ANEMONE)

MARTY SUPREME Sometimes the casting of a movie can tell you a lot about the film and the people who made it - even the smallest of roles. That's certainly the case with 'Marty Supreme,' the second feature that Josh Safdie has directed without his brother Benny. Safdie's film has two bits of striking casting. The first is Canadian businessman, 'Shark Tank' contributor and ardent Donald Trump supporter, Kevin O'Leary . Playing a successful businessman, O'Leary's casting tells you Safdie's movie is particularly fascinated by the mindset of entrepreneurs. However perhaps a more significant piece of casting is in a fringe role. Abel Ferrara , the director of controversial thrillers like ' Driller Killer ,' ' Ms 45 ' and ' Bad Lieutenant ' plays an ageing gangster. We'll come back to the significance of his involvement in the film. Let's focus on the plot first. Loosely based on the life of the  flamboyant American tabl...

BEING FRANK (THE NAKED GUN)

  THE NAKED GUN We all know Liam Neeson can do comedy. We've seen him do it before in small doses. The Northern Irish actor  had the best moment in Ricky Gervais' BBC sitcom 'Life's Too Short'  with his improv sketch. Then there was in  the cereal scene in Seth MacFarlane's 'Ted 2' . There have also been chances to test his comic chops in 'Derry Girls, '  on Stephen Colbert's chat show  and as  Good Cop/Bad Cop in 'The Lego Movie' . But can he carry a whole comic movie? Neeson gets the chance to find that out in Akiva Schaffer's 'The Naked Gun' - a reboot of  David Zucker's 1988 comedy classic with Leslie Nielsen, Priscilla Presley, George Kennedy and OJ Simpson . Produced by Seth MacFarlane and Erica Huggins and working from a script by Schaffer, Dan Gregor and Doug Mend, Neeson has a very high bar to clear - playing the son of Nielsen's bungling detective Frank Drebin. Like Frank Snr, Neeson's Frank Jr is an ...